Payments and billing: Creem, Paddle, Polar and Stripe compared

4 services for payments and billing: card payments, subscriptions, invoices and sales tax for an app. Compared on what decides the pick (merchant of record), how AI coding agents work with each one, and cost, from the makers' own pages.

Checked by CookiesForAI on : the 4 listed items were checked on that day.

Written by

Which one to choose

  • Choose Creem if you want a merchant of record with built-in affiliates, revenue splits and credit wallets for AI products.
  • Choose Paddle if you sell SaaS, apps or games and want a merchant of record with B2B invoicing and payment recovery.
  • Choose Polar if you want a merchant of record whose own platform code is open source on GitHub.
  • Choose Stripe if you want to stay the seller and control checkout, or pay out to sellers on your platform.

All four support MCP, skills, CLI and llms.txt. Pricing for all four: no monthly fee, a fee per payment.

Payments and billing compared
ServiceMerchant of record
CreemChecked YesIt sells to your buyer and handles sales tax.
PaddleChecked YesIt sells to your buyer and handles sales tax.
PolarOpen source (Apache-2.0)Checked YesIt sells to your buyer and handles sales tax.
StripeChecked NoYou are the seller and handle sales tax.Stripe Managed Payments makes Stripe the merchant of record for eligible digital products such as SaaS and software.

Agent links go to the maker's own pages. A missing link means we found none on the day we checked, not that it does not exist.

What each one does